cover for Planet Palm

Planet Palm (2021)

How Palm Oil Ended Up in Everything— and Endangered the World

Jocelyn C. Zuckerman

rating not-good
type nonfiction audiobook
concepts economics history/modern sustainable-agriculture
2021/12/18 Definitely opened my eyes to yet another incredibly corrupt and horrendous industry in our world, but the book wandered to all sorts of seemingly irrelevant places and could have been much more direct, concise, and powerful.

Intro

  • Palm oil and palm kernel oil permeate over 50% consumer products in the grocery store— how did we get here, and what is the impact of this industry?
    • Plant is semi-spontaneous in regeneration
  • Part 1 will look at origins of industry, spanning back two centuries, from POV of "colonizer"
  • Part 2 will look at it from the other side

Part 1

  • Development of palm oil trade tied tightly to "scramble for Africa," slave trade, etc.
  • Commodified in soap starting with Lever (→ Unilever), margarine
    • One scientist defected to P&G and helped them make Crisco!
  • Again, closely intertwined with atrocities in the Congo, etc.
  • Also spread the oil palm to Southeast Asia, exploitation happened there as well
    • Unilever's plantation people imported thousands of weevils from Africa to Malaysia once they found out the insect was the palm's main pollinator → increase in yield
  • Palm oil began replacing many other animal-based oils (butter, lard) in both industrial and home cooking
  • Used widely in oleo-chemicals (in place of petro-chemicals)

Part 2

  • Land-grabs in Indonesia = state-sponsored; plantation owners profited and benefited from anti-Communist massacres in the 60s-70s?
  • Deforestation/land-clearing to plant oil palms → so many endangered species, poaching in what little rainforest remains
  • Currently: labor conditions are horrendous
    • Extremely low (if any) wages, exposure to toxic pesticides (organophosphates) and other dangerous conditions (electrocution, etc.) with little healthcare
    • Child labor, sexual assault, etc.
    • Palm oil produced under such conditions makes its way into consumer goods in many companies we interact with— Hershey's, P&G, Pepsico, etc.
  • Murder and intimidation of union workers and strikers
  • India = one of the largest importers of palm oil; contributes to obesity and diabetes epidemics
    • Both palm oil and palm kernel oil have ideal properties for frying and things like chocolate, respectively (in terms of taste, saturation, etc.)
    • Emphasis and use of palm oil takes place of healthier options— both in agricultural space and actual food people are eating
    • Cheaper than other plant/vegetable oils (sunflower, rapeseed, etc.)
    • Used in place of dairy products like ghee, etc., as dairy prices rise (often not advertised clearly)
    • Prevalent in food that's locally produced and from international brands— which use palm oil in countries like India but not in the US
  • Similar trends in Mexico (obesity, cardiovascular disease)
  • Use of palm oil as biofuel lead to surge in production in Indonesia → more clear-cutting
    • Everywhere became fair game for palm plantations
    • Not necessarily carbon-neutral if clearing rainforest, or esp peat land, to grow the oil palms for biofuels

Part 3

  • Efforts in place to try to have food labels be more transparent when "tropical" vegetable oils are in use, more info on health and environmental implications
    • Resistance from food companies, plantation companies
  • Many certification schemes are not credible (rely on or influenced heavily by the companies they are supposed to regulate