skip to main content

How Science Beat the Virus ( 2020)

And what we lost in the process

Ed Yong

rating good
type nonfiction/journalism article
concepts public-health
2020/12/16 COVID both showcased advances in data-sharing, experimental speed, and vaccine development exposed flaws in science of “warped incentives, wasteful practices, overconfidence, inequality, a biomedical bias” → now we the scientific world has the chance to do what it can do best: self-correct.
  • COVID → unprecedented response from scientific community, in terms of volume and speed... hit Western science at home, when there were more researchers than ever before, drew diverse workforce

  • Massive breakthroughs (diagnostics, vaccine), but also major flaws: racial and gender inequality, financial inefficiency, misinformation... amplified the best and worst aspects of science.

  • Acceleration of science through preprints → more responsive; open-source datasets and tools.

  • "Platform technologies" approach to vaccine: ex. mRNA, take a sequence coding for a noninfectious fragment— very quick once genome published; also working on production, distribution in parallel. Likely changed vaccine development for good.

  • Treatments → many awful studies with bad design, going on & spreading misinformation — didn't have to be that way (compare to WWII; current UK initiative

  • Negative impacts of the shift in science

    • Slow down/halting of literally everything else, including long-term studies
    • "Epistemic tresspassing" or experts into other fields, making avoidable mistakes, reinventing the wheel
  • ~1850, social view of medicine (Rudolf Virchow):

    Medicine is a social science, and politics is nothing but medicine in larger scale.

    • Shifted away from this in late 19th c with discovery of microbes, etc., but coming back since late 20th c: environmentalism, impact of inequality and poverty on health
  • Disproportionate impact of COVID on people of color, people who simply can't stay home all the time (nonpharmaceutical interventions)...

    • Reality of how dependent things are on policy, behavioural change, etc. more clear than ever.
  • In summary: COVID both showcased advances in data-sharing, experimental speed, and vaccine development exposed flaws in science of "warped incentives, wasteful practices, overconfidence, inequality, a biomedical bias" → now we the scientific world has the chance to do what it can do best: self-correct.