cover for The Best Minds

The Best Minds (2024)

A Story of Friendship, Madness, and the Tragedy of Good Intentions

Jonathan Rosen

rating fantastic
type followup/book-rec nonfiction/autobiography audiobook
concepts psychology public-health
2024/08/02 Well! I started out extremely bored with this book, but was completely engaged by the 1/3 mark. Rosen writes about schizophrenia as it affects the suffering individual, their friends and family, and societal as a whole with admirable empathy’s and curiosity. I’ve thought a lot about the difficult decisions surrounding involuntary treatment for mental illness given my personal history with the pandemic subject, and Rosen articulates so many of the tensions between respecting someone’s independence / autonomy and preventing harm to themselves and others. I particularly resonated (sometimes uncomfortably) with the discussion of the specific challenges that arise when someone with a serious mental illness is outwardly “high-functioning,” and able to intellectualize their own pathology while internally drowning in their own mind — and the subsequent crisis when the facade breaks down. While I don’t have familiarity with schizophrenia, my own demons are similarly characterized by anosognosia— the belief that one is not ill — and my ongoing pursuits of higher education with a mental disability mirrored many of the experiences that Rosen explains his friend had at Yale Law School. I have lots more to think about with this book!
  • The eerie sound of a basketball bouncing on pavement echoing through a neighborhood
  • “I may be crazy, but I’m not stupid.”
  • Madness making achievement all that more impressive…
  • One of the challenges of schizophrenia is that people with it don’t accept their illness a
  • The incongruence between how articulate one can be discussing their own mental illness and the reality of their psychosis— rationality applies in all cases (“confusing intelligence with sanity”)
  • Law school → threat of constant humiliation
  • ~~Ellen Sacks~~ Elyn Saks — The Center Cannot Hold (another Yale Law School attendee with schizophrenia) #followup/book-rec
  • “The paradox of binaries is that they don’t mean there is no spectrum, just as a spectrum doesn’t mean there are no essential differences. A murky border is still a border. The problem was knowing who had the authority to establish it.”